If you’ve tried all the above and the water level is still threatening to become a swimming pool for hamsters, call a professional. Some things are worth the money—like not flooding your basement.
Also, if you see rusty water or hear weird gurgling sounds, that’s a sign of a deeper issue. Don’t ignore the gurgle. That’s your softener trying to talk to you.
And remember: it’s okay to ask for help. Even superheroes call for backup when they’re knee-deep in saltwater. You’re not failing at adulting—you’re just learning the plumbing arts.